discount oakley sunglasses Unlike most other brands of sunglasses that are mass produced in factories of China, detailed attention is given while manufacturing Persol sunglass in Italy.Cheap Oakley Sunglasses SaleCheap Oakley Sunglasses Sale Firstly, let's start with the basics - near-sightedness and far-sightedness; also known as myopia and hyperopia.Going one further, people - both farsighted and nearsighted - may also suffer from something called,oakley radar range sunglassesoakley polarized sunglassesoakley oil rig sunglassesoakley sunglasses cheapoakley sunglasses cheap 'astigmatism' which is basically when your cornea is curved (in the shape of a football rather than the shape of a basketball) and therefore,oakley monster dog sunglassesnew oakley sunglassesoakley antix sunglassesoakley sunglasses cheapoakley sunglasses cheap you see things blurred because your eye cannot focus clearly - no matter what the distance.Every dancing queen deserves a disco outfit with flares that you could build a house on.oakley c six sunglasses grey frame black lensoakley c six sunglasses black frame multicolor lensoakley c six sunglasses white frame yellow lensoakley sunglasses cheapoakley sunglasses cheap 3 rebounnds, was traded at the end of the season to the Charlotte Hornets for Larry Johnson.Mason palms the ball in one hand and hesitates several seconds before releasing it.Most people were comfortable with previous price range of $70-130,oakley scalpel sunglassesoakley radar range sunglassesoakley polarized sunglassesfake oakley sunglassesfake oakley sunglasses and 40% said that they would be willing to pay more if it was needed to cover costs.

lynnbakerjazz.com

Bring Competition Back to Music Education

September 2nd, 2010

discount oakley sunglasses Unlike most other brands of sunglasses that are mass produced in factories of China, detailed attention is given while manufacturing Persol sunglass in Italy.Cheap Oakley Sunglasses SaleCheap Oakley Sunglasses Sale Firstly, let's start with the basics - near-sightedness and far-sightedness; also known as myopia and hyperopia.Going one further, people - both farsighted and nearsighted - may also suffer from something called,oakley radar range sunglassesoakley polarized sunglassesoakley oil rig sunglassesoakley sunglasses cheapoakley sunglasses cheap 'astigmatism' which is basically when your cornea is curved (in the shape of a football rather than the shape of a basketball) and therefore,oakley monster dog sunglassesnew oakley sunglassesoakley antix sunglassesoakley sunglasses cheapoakley sunglasses cheap you see things blurred because your eye cannot focus clearly - no matter what the distance.Every dancing queen deserves a disco outfit with flares that you could build a house on.oakley c six sunglasses grey frame black lensoakley c six sunglasses black frame multicolor lensoakley c six sunglasses white frame yellow lensoakley sunglasses cheapoakley sunglasses cheap 3 rebounnds, was traded at the end of the season to the Charlotte Hornets for Larry Johnson.Mason palms the ball in one hand and hesitates several seconds before releasing it.Most people were comfortable with previous price range of $70-130,oakley scalpel sunglassesoakley radar range sunglassesoakley polarized sunglassesfake oakley sunglassesfake oakley sunglasses and 40% said that they would be willing to pay more if it was needed to cover costs.

An Interesting Idea

Recently, I was having a conversation with a retired band director and he told me he could identify the moment that music programs, specifically band programs, started losing numbers. He recounted how, early in his career, many “5A” bands in the Denver Metro area were marching 180 to 240 students. And some of those were not marching freshmen classes of close to 100! There was a very strong band community that is not present now and had a theory about why this happened.

Now, before I let you know what his theory was I want you to know that I don’t believe there was any bias associated with his comment. I don’t know him THAT well, but from what I do know of him, I think his comment was not motivated by anything other than an interpretation of the forces that played out at this time. OK, with that little disclaimer out of the way – here’s his theory.

He believe he could trace the decline in music program enrollment specifically to the enactment of Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972. The crux of the law is that there shall be no discrimination based on sex (I understand that to be biological gender, but I may be wrong) under any educational program receiving Federal financial assistance.  His opinion was that schools interpreted this law to apply mostly to sports, though athletics is not specified in the law.  That interpretation caused a ballooning of varsity and jr. varsity sports, especially in the fall, from “three to eleven.”  He also lamented the ancillary result that coaches of those sports further occupied the student-athletes’ time with extensive conditioning routines when their sports were not in session.

It was an interesting assertion and I don’t know if it was true or not, but for the sake of discussion lets assume he is correct.  It implies there was something provided by athletic programs that was not provided by music programs, and that extra something caused the students to choose athletics over music.

A woman in the discussion offered that the extra something may have been parental encouragement.  Many parents encourage their children to pursue athletics in hopes of financial success – either through collegiate athletic scholarships or lucrative careers in sports.  She is probably correct – though it is quite easy to demonstrate that outstanding musicians receive handsome music scholarships and the likelihood of a career in professional sports is less likely than a professional career in music.  However, perception is frequently not related to facts – so I’ll acknowledge parental encouragement toward athletics had some roll in the declining music program enrollment.

The Question Begged

And yet, I think there is something else that was much more important.  I believe that athletics provided students with a thrill, a charge.  Students got their jollies from participating in athletics that music did not provide and therefore left music for athletics.  And I think the heart of the “jolt” that motivates teenagers so well is competition.

I understand how competition became vilified in music education.  I heard too many jazz ensembles working the same three contest pieces for months, polishing their performance for the festivals they hoped to “win.”  Too many bands rote learning pieces so they could earn a “I” at competition.  And I understand how directors became motivated to pursue this path – sometimes for the sake of saving their own jobs!  All that time spent and very little music learned – and the experience very frequently resulting in young musicians who did not continue participating in music.

However, the reaction to these abuses was frequently an over-reaction of removing all forms of competition from the educational experience.  Competition in music was made into a dirty word – and yet as a professional musician I know that competition is always present in my professional life.

The misconception is that musicians compete with each other as we perform music – that we are trying to “win” a performance as if it were a sporting contest.  Musicians don’t compete with each other as we play.  However, we do compete to have the opportunity to perform music together.  This distinction needs to be made and needs to be present in our educational programs.

There are many benefits to competition, most obviously competition motivates young musicians to work harder.  Competition highlights the aspects of our technique or musicianship that need improvement and therefore is a brilliant pedagogical tool.  And the success of gaining the higher chair, the opportunity to play a solo, or the coveted chair in the top ensemble provides that thrill that athletics also provide.

How to Construct Positive Competition Experiences

Before continuing I need to stress we must make a strong distinction between competing TO perform and performing AS competition.  We need not reinvent the wheel, there are several practices that can be revived within this new context:

Chair “challenges” – providing opportunities for young musicians to advance to a higher chair.  This will help in many ways, one of the most obvious is an advanced level of ability that will save much more rehearsal time than is taken by hearing occasional “challenges.”

Regular auditions – the prime arena of musical competition in the professional world.  We should make regular auditions part of the educational experience, and those auditions should occasionally be conducted in a “blind” environment.

Jazz Jam sessions – can have that “cutting session” quality that brings all players to a higher level. They also let truly motivated and advanced players shine and provide them with an opportunity to judge their abilities.

Many other positive competition experiences are possible but it is crucial that the positive benefits of competing TO perform are always distinguished from the negative effects of performing AS competition.

It is true that music, by large measure, is a communitarian and cooperative activity.  But musical growth can be encouraged through competition.  And who knows, if music had “competed” with athletics for the hearts of youth in 1972 we might have a different present than we see – and more importantly hear, now.

3 Responses to “Bring Competition Back to Music Education”

  1. Chip Michael

    I couldn’t agree more. As a student (albeit graduate student), I find the lack of competition, the need for “everyone to have their chance” frustrating. The result is some good work gets lumped in with a lot of mediocre work and eventually those students that try to excel just stop putting in the effort.

    I remember (back in the late 70’s) having to audition for chair advancement. While I was fortunate (or talented) enough to always sit first chair I didn’t take it lightly – because my second chair was always challenging me to take my spot. We were best friends and remain in close contact 30 years later.

    Competition is PART of life and our education should prepare us for it.

  2. lynn

    I just returned from the 2010 Midwest Clinic and one of the bands I heard made me think of this thread.

    The Texas A&M Symphonic Winds comes from a school that does not have a music program, their band program is a student club of 800 members. There are several ensembles within the program and the elite band is the Symphonic Winds of about 65 musicians. They played an outstanding concert in the featured slot at this year’s Midwest. This is the potential of positive competition. With 800 musicians to choose from, the most ambitious 8% elevate themselves to this ensemble which plays challenging classic and new literature at a very high musical level. Congratulations to the Texas A&M student, faculty, and staff for a great concert and program and for providing a marvelous example of healthy competition in music.

  3. JBFletcher

    In the 50’s and 60’s ‘healthy competition in music’ was evident. Within the ensemble as well as between groups – even in the Marching band with it’s athletic components.

    So what do they do now? Take turns at First Chair?
    Are there no Parade honors between groups? No city-wide or state competitions?

    Bet you had a great time in Texas. Looks like you brought some sun back with you.

Leave a Reply

Proudly powered by WordPress. Theme developed with WordPress Theme Generator.
Copyright © lynnbakerjazz.com. All rights reserved.

discount oakley sunglasses Unlike most other brands of sunglasses that are mass produced in factories of China, detailed attention is given while manufacturing Persol sunglass in Italy.Cheap Oakley Sunglasses SaleCheap Oakley Sunglasses Sale Firstly, let's start with the basics - near-sightedness and far-sightedness; also known as myopia and hyperopia.Going one further, people - both farsighted and nearsighted - may also suffer from something called,oakley radar range sunglassesoakley polarized sunglassesoakley oil rig sunglassesoakley sunglasses cheapoakley sunglasses cheap 'astigmatism' which is basically when your cornea is curved (in the shape of a football rather than the shape of a basketball) and therefore,oakley monster dog sunglassesnew oakley sunglassesoakley antix sunglassesoakley sunglasses cheapoakley sunglasses cheap you see things blurred because your eye cannot focus clearly - no matter what the distance.Every dancing queen deserves a disco outfit with flares that you could build a house on.oakley c six sunglasses grey frame black lensoakley c six sunglasses black frame multicolor lensoakley c six sunglasses white frame yellow lensoakley sunglasses cheapoakley sunglasses cheap 3 rebounnds, was traded at the end of the season to the Charlotte Hornets for Larry Johnson.Mason palms the ball in one hand and hesitates several seconds before releasing it.Most people were comfortable with previous price range of $70-130,oakley scalpel sunglassesoakley radar range sunglassesoakley polarized sunglassesfake oakley sunglassesfake oakley sunglasses and 40% said that they would be willing to pay more if it was needed to cover costs.